Hopefully by the time you are reading this, Minnie’s Island will be re-opened to the public, given the high water we are experiencing over the Memorial Day weekend, but as of now, it is still closed, due to concerns over the sediment along the shorelines and at the canoe landings.
About a month after the start of DC Water’s sewage spill, Minnie’s Island Community Conservancy (MICC), along with the Sycamore Island Club and Canoe Cruisers Association, asked DC Water to test the sediment in areas that are frequently used for recreation.
DC Water never responded to our requests. Even after water quality testing for E. coli had returned to normal levels, we knew something was off with the canoe landings used to access Minnie’s Island.
The landing on the island is essentially an upstream-facing cove that has standing water during low river flows, such as we had back in January. Through early April, we could still smell sewage at the landings, and the quantities of muck/mud at the landings were greater than any of us could remember.
Since our requests for sediment testing were ignored by DC Water, we shifted our focus to working with the Maryland Department of the Environment (MDE), and in early April, MDE collected sediment at Minnie’s Island canoe landings for testing.
We’ve learned a lot about sediment testing since then. The Environmental Protection Agency has clear standards for testing of E. coli in water along with thresholds for safe recreational use (410 MPN/100ml).
However, there are no established standards for collection, testing, or assessing safe levels for E. coli in sediment. MDE took their first sediment samples at Minnie’s in mid-April, but results using their initial testing methodology were inconclusive.
MDE then worked with a different laboratory using a more sensitive testing approach, and results were finally available in mid-May. MDE and their testing partner at the University of Maryland emphasized that they were pushing the bounds of science with this work.
Testing results are shown in the accompanying figure. The two high bars are the results from E. coli testing at Minnie’s from April 14. What stands out here is the results for the two Minnie’s Island sites were significantly (maybe 100 times?) higher than the results for other sites on April 14.
Again, there are no health-impact standards for E. coli in sediment; however, the results were sufficient for Montgomery County Health Officer Dr. Kisha Davis to amend the health advisory for shore line areas affected by the spill.
This latest advisory, dated May 18, urges the public to avoid contact with the shoreline and river sediment between Lock 11 and the shoreline surrounding Minnie’s Island. The advisory notes that it is important to keep children and pets away from these specific areas.
Based on this information, the MICC Board is keeping the island closed to visitors. What is it going to take for us to open? Likely two events–the first being Montgomery County lifting the advisory, and the second being at least one high water event (hopefully rainy Memorial Day weather) that can dilute and flush much of the remaining sediment from the nooks and crannies around the island.
In the meantime, nature continues at the island, unconcerned with EPA standards. All of the fifteen oak trees we planted last year are doing very well, and the forty trees and shrubs we planted earlier this year are hanging in there, despite the drought.
We’re pleased that black vultures appear to be nesting again on the rock outcrops, and I observed a mink for the first time on the shoreline. Board members do occasionally go to the island to water our new plantings and perform maintenance on the cabin and the land at least seems back to normal.
We’re looking forward to when we can invite everyone back out!
By Joe Saliunas, certified Maryland Master Naturalist and Board Chair of Minnie’s Island Community Conservancy
Contributing Writer