The Community of Cabin John Maryland Search Support CJCA

A Massive Development Plan Could Have Razed Cabin John in 1959

The community of Cabin John has evolved since its earliest days in 1913, when J.S. Tomlinson’s American Land Company began offering lots to intrepid folks searching for a bucolic place outside of the city to call home.

He advertised his new development in the “splendid location” of Cabin John Park, with its “refreshing breezes, running streams, fertile land and abundant shade trees.” Yet while many houses have changed in the growing neighborhood, together with the addition of MacArthur Plaza, that pastoral vision has remained.

In the September 2024 Village News, I wrote about the 1971 Cabin John Community Plan, born out of the potential loss of the neighborhood’s semi-rural character as developers seized on its location and unused tracts of land.

One developer, the Bogley & Co. real estate brokerage, proposed a large scale project in 1959, which was ultimately stopped due to community pushback. I recently came across several more newspaper articles in the Montgomery County Sentinel in 1959-60 that detailed just how enormous a project this was—it would have ultimately obliterated Cabin John as we know it.

Bogley & Co., headed by the “soft spoken young man” Robert W. Lebling, proposed a nearly $100 million plan that covered some 420 acres and included “luxury apartments with a river view….a 50 or 60 acre shopping area on the order of Prince George’s Plaza, an office and research park for ‘clean’ industry on about 100 acres, a motel and supper club on about 40 acres and a 20 acre site hopefully set aside for a federal agency of some sort.”

It was rumored that Lebling had made a direct offer to purchase Cabin John Gardens, which had only just been turned into a cooperative several years earlier.

In attempts to woo residents to sell, Lebling sent out a letter and his own “confidential” petition to property owners about his plan to rezone the Cabin John Triangle, so called because of the anticipated completion of the beltway and GW Parkway.

The citizens association, which had initially “offered to cooperate in an open and unbiased polling of community opinion after due consideration” of Lebling’s proposal, was not pleased, and its president, John Jessup, urged residents not to participate in Lebling’s survey.

One resident noted that Lebling’s petition was “so worded that an indication favoring a restudy of the Cabin John Watershed Master Plan would also constitute a recommendation that Lebling’s plan be adopted in its stead.”

Morris Fradin, who had been a resident of Cabin John since the early 1940s, called the “‘cloud No. 9 project an attempt to spur panic selling so that the residents would sell out and get out” and warned fellow residents “to be alert to more such psychological pressures designed to speed sales.”

The citizens association meetings with Lebling and his associate, Buford M. Hayden, were contentious. Mrs. Wilson Frazier quipped, to great applause, “I don’t think anyone has our personal interests at heart.

You speak of ideal sites for riverside apartments; well, I like the view too, and I like to take my children down there to see it.” Mother of two and PTA officer Mrs. Jerry Shaw stated, “I’m willing to hang on forever.

This may be a community of individuals, but one thing we all have in common is our desire to stay.”

Perhaps Mrs. Don Iglehart best summed up community opinion on Lebling’s proposal: “These people keep talking about progress and feel sorry for us. They say we’re five miles away from where we can buy a loaf of bread. Well, we like it that way. That’s why we came.”

Nearly three-quarters of Cabin John residents were against the shockingly massive plan, and passionate community opposition effectively put an end to it. A decade later, the community shared their vision of Cabin John’s future: a quiet atmosphere, small own friendliness, many trees and a diversity of homes, people and cultures.

This vision formed the basis of the Cabin John Community Plan, later incorporated into the 1990 Bethesda-Chevy Chase Master Plan. While residents no longer need to go five miles for a loaf of bread, community engagement has allowed Cabin John to retain its unique character and small town charm.

By Rachel Donnan, CJ Historian, Contributing Writer

Search Cabin John

Search stories, pages and the text inside full newsletter PDFs. Use arrow keys to browse and Escape to close.

Search the website and newsletter PDFs

    Try a name, place or story topic.

    ↑↓ to browse Enter to openEsc to closeTap a result to open the document