The Holly and the Ivy (Berries, that is)
Walking along the C&O Canal in Cabin John this month I’ve noticed fruits on some of our trees and shrubs. This caused me to ask some questions. Many of the fruits are eaten by birds, but why do some fruits remain until late winter or early spring?
Why are some fruits more beneficial to bird life than others? Why do some fruits have an overall negative impact on our local ecosystem? In this column I’ll answer these questions and explain why American holly fruit is primarily beneficial, while English ivy fruits are detrimental to the ecosystem.
First, let’s address timing: I know of several areas with American holly trees that are always filled with berries through the fall. These berries typically remain until sometime in mid-winter.
Then for several days, the trees are filled with robins, cedar waxwings, eastern bluebirds and other over-wintering birds, and they are stripped clean of fruits. For some shrubs and trees, frost and thaw cycles break down bitter compounds and increase sugars, making the fruits more palatable and energy-rich.
Birds will start the winter by eating the most desirable fruits first, waiting for the other fruits to be transformed later in winter. Examples of these late-winter survival fruits include hollies, viburnum, dogwood, bayberry, and sumac.
However, if food is scarce, birds may start eating them in late fall.
Now, let’s address why some fruits are more beneficial for birds than others. The rule of thumb is that fruit from native shrubs and trees has higher fat content than fruit from non-native, invasive plants.
This is why migrating birds will go out of their way to find and eat the fruit of native plants, even if non-native fruit is available. A study by Rochester Institute of Technology measured the fat percentage of common invasive species (bush honeysuckle, buckthorn, and multi-flora rose) at less than one percent.
Compare this to the fat content for native dogwood, viburnum, and spicebush at 25-50%. Spicebush are very common along the C&O Canal and Minnie’s Island, as deer don’t like their aromatic leaves.
This year was a very good fruit production year, and most of these high-energy spicebush fruits were gone by mid-fall.
Finally, let’s address good vs. bad fruits from an overall eco-system health perspective. I remember taking a walk on Cabin John Island in the late winter, when I noticed a large number of robins eating the fruit from large English ivy vines growing on a sycamore (note that I would have cut the vines but the tree was leaning over Cabin John Creek).
In doing research for this article, I found that English ivy fruits are high in fat/energy, and thus good for birds. However, as long as the birds eat the fruit, they will be excreting the seeds all over the island, which ultimately limits plant diversity and impacts native plant populations as the ivy spreads.
Other non-native invasive plants are particularly bad–low energy fruits that spread the plant to new areas. Examples of this include oriental bittersweet, porcelain berry, and Japanese honeysuckle.
The bottom line for landowners and bird enthusiasts is to remove the invasive shrubs and vines, and leave room (or plant) native plants. Many common native vines and shrubs are great for our resident and migrating birds. If you watch carefully, you may be able to witness a multi-day feeding frenzy.
By Joe Saliunas, Maryland Master Naturalist, Board Chair of Minnie’s Island Community Conservancy
Contributing Writer