(Please see an important update provided by the developer after the meeting at the end of this article)
A standing-room-only crowd of close to 100 people gathered at Clara Barton Neighborhood Recreation Center on December 12, 2024, for a presentation by the potential developers of 7687 MacArthur Boulevard, which is at the corner of 77th Street and MacArthur Boulevard and is currently occupied by Level Fitness.
The potential developers are Bethesda-based Broad Branch Partners, headed by Shane Crowley and Jason Weinstein. Both spoke at the meeting. Also present was their lawyer, Matthew Gordon of Selzer Gurvitch, and their civil engineer.
The property owner, former Cabin John resident Jim Wilner, was represented at the meeting by CJ resident James Cahill, who specializes in landlord representation services and investment sales brokerage.
The developers began by describing other projects they have completed in the area, including 6970 West Avenue, Bethesda, where they built three new luxury 4-bedroom, 4-and-a-half bath elevator “Smart Home” townhouse condos that they are selling for $2.8 million each.
Another property mentioned was 4702 West Virginia Avenue in Bethesda, where they recently received site plan approval to build a 125,000 square foot 11-story highrise that will include 53 condominiums, 6 townhouses and a 100-space parking garage.
The discussion shifted to their plans for 7687 MacArthur Blvd., a 0.42-acre parcel (21,000 square feet) that currently has three buildings totaling some 6,200 square feet of space and 16 parking spaces.
The current selling price is $3.15 million ($509 per square foot). At the time of the meeting, the developer’s plan was to build 11 luxury townhomes, four in one building facing MacArthur Blvd. and seven in a second building facing 77th Street.
Generally, each unit would be four stories, 44 feet in height with a flat roof and a two-car garage on the ground floor. There would be a 20-foot wide private alley to allow cars to enter and exit their garages, but no off-street parking for the owners or their visitors.
The setback from 77th Street would include a five-foot buffer from the curb and a six-foot wide sidewalk. The street width would remain 50 feet wide. The asking price per unit is anticipated to be between $1.5 million and $2 million.
The developers have not yet bought the property and it seems that any sale would be contingent on the successful map amendment to change the zoning of the property. Currently, 75% of the property is zoned C-1 (according to the real estate listing) or CRT (according to the developers). The C-1 and CRT designations allow for a range of business uses.
The other 25% of the property, roughly 5,000 to 6,000 square feet is zoned R-90, which is typically used for single-family detached homes and requires a 30-foot setback from the street and a minimum rear setback of 25 feet with lots recorded between 1941 and 1954 allowed to have a rear set back of 20 feet.
The building height restriction for R-90 is 35 feet to roof peak or 30 foot to mean height between eaves and ridge of gable, hip, mansard or gambrel roof. A number of residents raised concerns about the planned building height, but the developers did not express any flexibility on that issue.
The developers are proposing to rezone the whole property to CRN–commercial/residential neighborhood. The developers pointed out that this rezoning would put limits on the kinds of commercial enterprises that could be located on the land, while making it suitable for their townhouse development.
However, the CRN rezoning would also raise the allowable density of the 25% of the property that is currently zoned R-90. The developers made it clear that their development plan does not work without the R-90 portion of the property rezoned to CRN.
At different times during the meeting, the developers and Jim Cahill suggested that if the property is not rezoned and the development does not move forward, the community could find the property bought by an implied undesirable business, citing as examples a dry cleaner, an auto body shop, an overnight methadone clinic or ”a daycare with 200 cars entering and exiting the property every day.”
One resident let the developers know that this property is one of only a handful of commercial properties in Cabin John. Generally, the community appreciates its local retailers and the businesses that have operated 7687 MacArthur Blvd. have been good neighbors.
Past enterprises have included a hair salon, an antiques shop, a canoe and kayak retailer, and the Wild Bird Center. For the past 20 years, Level Fitness has leased the space.
The developers outlined a timeline for rezoning:
- Submission of Local Map Amendment application to the Maryland-National Capital Parks and Planning Commission (M-NCPPC): January 2025
- Review of Local Map Amendment Application by M-NCPPC and the county planning board: 1st Quarter 2025
- Review of Local Map Amendment Application by Office of Zone and Hearing Examiner: Spring 2025
- Review of Local Map Amendment Application by County Council: Summer 2025
- Additional Pre-Submission Community Meeting for Preliminary Plan/Site Plan: Summer 2025
- Planning Board Review of Preliminary Plan/Site Plan Applications: Late 2025-Early 2026
There was no additional discussion on the process so it is not clear if this represents all the steps in the county’s rezoning process. Nor were details provided about when the developers would actually purchase the lot.
While the rezoning requirements do not include soil studies, stormwater management plans or parking and traffic impacts, residents raised those concerns as part of the meeting. The plan clearly reduces the green footprint of the property which could have drainage consequences.
The developer explained that their plan would incorporate significant stormwater management into the landscaping on a strip of land on the east side of the property. It sounds as if drainage spouts from the buildings would be buried underneath the alleyway and flow to this rainscape-landscape.
The developers acknowledged that they are aware that the open gully along MacArthur Blvd. is where stormwater runoff flows from 77th Street. Residents pointed out that this gully currently fills and occasionally floods over, sending water down into the MacArthur Park townhome development across MacArthur Blvd. The developers acknowledged that they have not driven down into the MacArthur Park development and seemed unaware that it consists of 45 townhomes on 10.5 acres, a much more bucolic townhouse development in keeping with the Cabin John community.
Regarding the traffic impact, the developer said the county traffic studies use standard traffic models for differing property types and would indicate a lower traffic impact than possible commercial applications of the property.
However, the number of housing units on 77th Street would almost double, from 12 homes currently to 23 dwellings. Residents also raised concerns regarding trash collection management, parking and street navigation.
Twice the crowd applauded residents who spoke about this proposed development not being consistent with the neighborhood and the Cabin John community at large.
UPDATE: On December 18, 2024, attorney Matthew Gordon representing Broad Branch Partners emailed CJCA: “I will be in touch with more detail in January, but I wanted to provide a quick update.
My client heard the feedback and is now going back to the drawing board to develop a plan with less density and building height and will pursue development as permitted by the current zoning for the property (i.e., rezoning is no longer being pursued).”