As we know, Montgomery County has issues with housing. With a population of over one million people, and expected growth of 200,000 in the next 25 years, there is simply not enough housing planned to accommodate that growth.
Furthermore, some members of the business community believe the cost of housing, which has escalated dramatically over the past several decades, will drive businesses and people away, particularly downcounty.
Enter the Attainable Housing Strategies initiative, which is currently being advocated for by the Montgomery County Council, of which Andrew Friedson is president and our District 1 Councilmember.
The primary goal of AHS is to develop recommendations to increase options for property owners to build more housing types in the county, particularly along the county’s growth corridors as set out in the approved Thrive Montgomery 2050 plan.
Growth corridors are centered around transit stations and along mixed-use corridors that are walkable, bikeable and transit-accessible.
While an obvious approach is higher-density housing, such as large multi-family buildings, this is not the ideal solution because more than a third of the county is still zoned exclusively for single-family housing.
The intent of AHS is to provide an opportunity to look at zoning laws to determine if a middle ground to increase the number of units can be found all the while maintaining neighborhood character.
The Facts:
The AHS initiative consists of three types of housing density plans:
For Cabin Johners, the small scale recommendations from the AHS would be most applicable (to the extent this program has been developed). The County Planning Board recommends new house-scale (i.e., existing lot-line setbacks and height restrictions) attainable housing be permitted by right in the R‑40, R‑60, R‑90 and R‑200 zones as follows:
- duplexes everywhere in the R-40, R-60, R-90, and R-200 zones;
- triplexes everywhere in the R-40, R-60, and R-90 zones, and in the R-200 zone within a Priority Housing District;* and
- quadplexes in the R-40, R-60, R-90, and R-200 zones within the Priority Housing District.*
*Note that Cabin John is not within the county’s Priority Housing District.
Most homes in Cabin John south of Archbold Terrace and Longridge Court are located in the R-90 zone, while those in Cabin John Gardens fall under the R-60 zone. Homes north of Archbold Terrace and Longridge Court are designated R-200.
If elements of the AHS are adopted in their current form, property owners could have the opportunity to increase housing density in these ways: in the R-60 or R-90 zones, a detached single-family home could be replaced with a duplex or triplex and in the R-200 zone, a detached single-family home could be replaced with a duplex.
The Status
The AHS is only a set of recommendations at this point. No legislation is up for consideration and any draft legislation would require public hearings. County administration just wrapped up its series of six listening sessions, intended for residents to weigh in on the proposed initiative, with the last held on October 2. The CJCA is in information-gathering mode at this time.
The Feedback
CJCA officers were in attendance at the listening session held at Bethesda-Chevy Chase High School on September 25. Examples of comments and concerns expressed by the public regarding the potential AHS initiative included (in no particular order):
- Many recognize the need for increased density and agree something must be done.
- The county needs to increase its tax base. Too many people and businesses are moving out of Maryland for a myriad of reasons (cost of living, lack of housing, regulations, taxes, jobs).
- Many argued that such an impactful change to zoning regulations should be placed on the ballot for the public to decide and not be left to the County Council.
- Many expressed concerns with how increased density would impact the “peace and tranquility” of single-family housing neighborhoods and potentially reduce property values.
- There were questions about the role of developers in the AHS process and any subsequent legislation.
- What additional investments in public transit are being made to support AHS?
- Given that many MCPS schools are at or over capacity, a) how would the schools manage the increased enrollment, and b) should the county be more concerned with addressing the school overcrowding instead of emphasizing AHS?
- Has sufficient due diligence been performed? Can the data be shared? For example, what have we learned from the impact of allowing the construction of accessory dwelling units (ADUs)? How many ADUs have been built, where are they, and who occupies them? What about the current stock of planned housing units?
- Our county executive has come out against the recommendations.
- A new duplex in Cabin John–with all the typical new home bells and whistles–would hardly be priced below an “attainable” $1 million.
- Would there be attainable housing–under $750k–anywhere in the priority areas close to Metro?
- The Chevy Chase Lake development was cited as an example of the impact on single-family home neighborhoods, i.e. resultant high traffic and high noise with the higher density.
Cabin Johners are encouraged to visit https://montgomeryplanning.org/planning/housing/attainable-housing-strategies-initiative/ for more information. The next steps will be up to the Montgomery County Council.
Given the large impact and consequences of the AHS and its recommendations, there will be much feedback and, in many cases, pushback. The CJCA will continue to monitor the AHS and may make it the subject of an upcoming community meeting.
By Scott Lewis, Charlotte Troup-Leighton, and Marcy Harrison
Contributing Writers