No Development on 80th Place. Roots Before Roofs. Trees Not Drywells.
By now, nearly all of Cabin John has noticed the cute squirrel signs (and others) with a serious message against the proposed development on 80th Place. Potomac Heritage Homes plans to build four large, nearly identical houses in the 2.3-acre woods between 80th and 81st Streets, bulldozing more than half of one of the last large, undeveloped tracts of land in Cabin John.
Filled with majestic trees and teeming with wildlife, the woods adjoin the Carderock Conservation Area at the end of 80th Place. A stream runs through the middle, under MacArthur Boulevard and down toward the Potomac.
Residents of the surrounding streets have mobilized in an effort to halt this proposed development. Concerns include drainage issues, emergency vehicle access and destruction of the natural environment.
Clearing most of the wooded parcel would have a tremendous impact on wildlife and forever change the rural, woodsy character of Cabin John—one of the reasons people have chosen to live here since J.S. Tomlinson’s American Land Company began offering lots in 1913.
In fact, on Tomlinson’s early maps of Cabin John Park, this lot was intended to be a public space for a school and baseball field.
Many Cabin Johners attended recent contentious meetings with the builder to voice their disapproval and concerns. It’s reminiscent of another time in Cabin John’s history, when residents had a voice in determining the future of the community.
In 1959, Bogley & Co. real estate brokerage proposed a massive project in Cabin John that included a large shopping center, offices, a motel and luxury “apartment houses” to replace 350 modest homes in the area.
The Montgomery County Sentinel newspaper described the scheme in a July 30, 1959 article, “‘Dream Plan’ Viewed Dimly by Cabin John Residents.” Several locals quoted predicted that the plan would “fall flat on its face before it ever gets started.”
Andrew Wilkins, one of the founding members of the Cabin John Citizens Association in 1919, said “Personally, we love Cabin John and deeply resent promoters who claim to want to help the community but who really only want to make money and more money.”
Dr. Henry Briefs, an economist on the President’s Council of Economic Advisors, was shocked by the proposed development and said “We came out here to live, not to speculate in real estate.
We like to have a safe, friendly, small town atmosphere for our eight children and still be so close to the city… Capital appreciation is certainly not our first consideration.”
At a Cabin John Citizens Association special meeting, nearly three-quarters of the community expressed their dismay at the Bogley plan, and ultimately put a stop to the project.
Throughout the 1960s, developers conveyed interest in Cabin John’s unused parcels of land. Residents became increasingly worried about the potential loss of the neighborhood’s character and rural feel.
In 1971, a community survey was sent to all residents in which their vision of Cabin John emerged. The Cabin John Community Plan was born and was later incorporated into the Bethesda-Chevy Chase Master Plan.
The Cabin John Community Plan “contains our goals, objectives and proposals for the future of the area in which we live—and the assertion that we, the citizens, have both the right and the duty to direct the lifestyle we choose to follow, rather than have it done for us.”
Cabin John residents expressed their wishes to maintain a quiet atmosphere, small town friendliness, many trees and a diversity of homes, people and cultures.
The Bethesda-Chevy Chase Master Plan (1990) notes that the “unique character of the Cabin John community should be retained by keeping the existing scale and type of housing along with the semi-rural, wooded environment.
This community is one of the few areas in Bethesda-Chevy Chase providing a diversity of housing types at a range of prices. This mix results in an opportunity for housing for people who otherwise might not be able to live in the Palisades Area.
This is one important factor in the strong sense of community among the citizens of Cabin John. It is important that this neighborhood with its variety of housing be maintained.”
The Master Plan notes that the “Large stands of mature trees are not only a critical asset from an environmental perspective but also greatly contribute to the ambience associated with the area.”
While many of the original neighborhood houses have been sensitively renovated or replaced with larger ones, older homes remain too. Wooded yards and front porches dot the narrow roads.
Residents of Cabin John still embrace values of small town warmth, green surroundings, abundant trees, eclectic homes and a rustic aesthetic. Its self-defined identity continues to endure for now.
By Rachel Donnan
CJ Historian